A Clinical Approach to Ardita (Facial Palsy) through Ayurveda: A Single Case Study
Aggravated Vata, affects face & leads to impaired function of facial muscle. The term Ardita denotes facial paralysis or Bell’s palsy. Ardita comes under eighty Nanatmaja Vyadhi. Facial palsy is most common neurological disorder, in which seventh cranial nerve is affected. The facial nerve conveys both sensory & motor along with parasympathetic fibres. Damaged facial nerve (VII) results in loss of function of facial muscle leads to cosmetic impairment. In this manuscript we are presenting a case study of a 44 years old female patient with left LMN left hemifacial palsy with symptoms of weakness in the left side of body, drooping of angle of mouth towards the left side, difficulty in speech, difficulty in wrinkling of forehead in left side, lacrimation from left eyes, numbness in left side of face, altered sensation of taste. Ayurvedic & Herbal formulations like Buhat Vata Chintamani ras, Giloy Satva, Ashwgandha Churna, Trayodhashang Gugulu, etc along with the Panchkarma procedure has been given and treated for one week. Patient got complete relief with appreciable changes in all symptoms.
Introduction
Vata is responsible for controlling all the functions as well as formation of body structures. It is the only motivating force in the body, having propulsive action, through which it moves things & expels waste products from the body [1]. It controls central nervous functions, neuro-muscular activities & mind. It is responsible for all movements in the body hence under the term “Nanatmaja Vyadhi” of Vata 80 disease have been included which covers wide range of symptoms like paresis, paralysis of muscles, monoplegia, diplegia, hemiplegia, facial paralysis, neuralgia, stiffness of muscles, sciatica, spondylitis, convulsions, tremors, atrophy of muscles & cramps[2]. Acharya Charak has explained Ardita as the contracture of mouth along with the involvement of forehead, eyebrow, eye, nasial fold on the affected side of face [3]. Acharya Charak opines that Ardita is localized in half face with or without involvement of body. Acharya Sushruta has considered the involvement of face only [4]. Ardita is also termed as Ekayaam [5].
On the basis of symptoms Ardita can be correlated with facial palsy. Facial palsy is a common neurological disorder in which seventh cranial nerve is affected. 7th cranial nerve also known as facial nerve, responsible for all voluntary movement of face, taste to the anterior 2/3 of tongue as well as control of lacrimal gland & salivary gland secretions. Facial palsy is defined as a temporary inability to control the facial muscles on affected side of face [6]. It can be characterized by weakness, muscle twitching, or total loss of ability to move on affected side along with drooping of eyelid, pain around the ear and change in taste [6]. Typical symptoms come on over 48 hours. Its cause is unknown. On the basis of lesions it can be divided into two types, UMN & LMN lesion. If patient involves paralysis of lower face on the opposite side, it comes under UMN. If involves upper as well as lower face on same side, it comes under LMN. Here the patient has come with symptoms involving left unilateral side of face with both quadrants upper & lower, so representing the symptoms of LMN lesion of facial nerve.
The incidence is around 23 per 1, 00,000 people per year, or about 1 in 60-70 people in a lifetime [7]. It affects men and women more or less equally, with a peak incidence between the age of 10-40. It occurs with equal frequency on the right & left sides of the face [8].
Probable Pathogenesis According to Ayurveda [9]
When Vata is aggravated, it affects the one half part of body, it dries up blood, hand, legs, nee and produces contracture in that half. Consequently face, nose, eyebrows, forehead, eyes, jaw also get crooked. There is salivation and the eyes on the affected side remains partially closed. Thus when the food is taken, the morsel goes on the affected side, as the tongue also get affected. Patient may also face slurred speech. Some time may also feel pain in foot, hand, eyes, temple, ear & cheeks.
Case Study
A 44 years old female, housewife by occupation, belonging to the low middle class, came to Panchkarma OPD department of Rishikul campus, Haridwar, India with the following complaints from 1 week
- Weakness in the left side of face along with other body parts
- Numbness in the left half side of face
- Angle of mouth drooped down towards the left side of face
- Lacrimation from left eye
- Altered taste sensation & smell
- Slurred speech
- Inability to make facial expression like smile, frowning.
Associated Complaints
• Constipated bowels since 1 months
History of Present Illness
According to the patient, she was aymptomatic before one week; suddenly she felt weakness in left side of face along with generalized weakness. She also noticed that her angle of mouth droop down towards left side & numbness in left half side of face. Few hours later she also felt altered sensation of taste and smell with slurred speech. For this she came to Panchkarma OPD of Rishikul campus, Haridwar for management.
Past Medical History
- No significant history of same illness
- Patient is K/C/O hypertension for 1 year & DM for 3 month No H/o of fall, trauma or surgery.
- Patient does not have significant family history.
Personal History
- Appetite- reduced Thirst – reduced
- Dietary habit – vegetarian Micturition – normal
- Bowel – constipated, once in three days, consistency is hard Sleep – disturbed
- Addiction – not any
General Examination
- BP- 110/80 mm of hg
- Pulse- 78/min
- Temperature – afebrile R/R – 18/min
- Edema – not present
- Pallor – not present
- Icterus – not present
- Tongue – white coated
- Skin – dry
Systemic Examination
Patient was conscious & well oriented to time, place & person. Higher function like intelligence, memory, behavior, emotions are normal. Speech was slurred. Superficial & deep reflexes were normal. All the cranial nerves are intact except VII nerve i.e. facial nerve.
| Affected on left side | |
|---|---|
| Forehead frowning | Affected on left side |
| Eyebrow raising | Affected on left side |
| Eye closure | Incomplete closure of left eyelid |
| Teeth showing | Not possible on left side |
| Blowing of cheek | Not possible on left side |
| Nasolabial fold | Loss on left side |
| Taste perception | Affected |
| Dribbling of saliva | Absent |
| Bells phenomenon | Present on left side |
| Deviation of mouth | Towards right side |
Table 1: Facial nerve examination.
All the deep reflexes such as biceps, triceps, brachio- radialis, knee jerk, ankle jerk, planter reflex are normal.
Muscle tone & power are normal in all the limbs. Systemic examination of cardiovascular & respiratory system was observed normal. During the abdominal examination there was tenderness in hypo-chondrium region, rest thing was found normal.
Investigations
- Hematological reports, lipid profile, LFT, KFT were normal but sugar level raised (RBS- 220 mg/dl)
- MRI head shows normal study.
Diagnosis
Considering the symptoms & examinations, the condition was diagnosed as case of Ardita / facial palsy. Written informed consent from patient was taken prior to treatment. Study was carried out by following the good clinical practice.
Plan of Treatment
Considering the diagnosis, patient was treated on the line of treatment for Ardita. Internal medicine – all for 60 days
- Bruhat vata chintamani ras- 100mg – Twice daily with milk after meal
- Giloy satva-200mg – twice daily with milk after meal
- Dhatri loh – 200 mg – twice daily with milk after meal
- Ashwgandha churna – 2 gm – twice daily with milk after meal
- Trayodashang gugulu- 2 tablet twice daily with water after meal
- Tab mentate- 2 tablet twice daily with water after meal
- Dashmoolharitaki avleha- 20 gm with hot milk during hours of sleep
- Inj. neurobion forte – 2ml (IM) at alternate day for one week Panchkarma Therapy Details Planned for marsh Nasya with Mashbaladi Pachana kashaya Nasya along with pan.
Nasya Purva Karma: Sthanika Abhyanga with Go Ghrita, Nadi Swedana with Dashmoola Kwath Pradhan Karma: Mashbaladi Pachan Kashaya Nasya in two sittings (each sitting of 7 days with the gap of three days) Paschat Karma: Kavala Dharan with lukewarm water followed by Dhoompana. Note: Mashbaladi Pachana Kashaya Pan about 100ml/day for 14 days.
Results
After 7 days of therapy with internal medication, she got significant relief in complaints like lacrimation, numbness on left side of face, correction of facial symmetry, no difficulty in speaking.
Clinical assessments were made from the subjective symptoms & House-Brackmann’s grading of facial nerve VII. The result was seen after 7 days of treatment. There was no side effect observed during & after the treatment.
| Parameter | Before Treatment | After Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Deviation of mouth towards right side | Grade IV | Grade II |
| Dribbling of saliva | Dribbling absent | Dribbling absent |
| Nasolabial fold | Loss from left side of mouth | Normal |
| Slurred speech | Mild difficulty in pronouncing | Normal speech |
| Lacrimation | Continuous lacrimation from left eye | Lacrimation absent |
| Chewing | Difficulty in chewing from left side | Easily chew from left side |
| Taste sensation | Altered | Normal |
Table 2: Subjective parameters.
| Before Treatment | After Treatment of 7 Days | |
|---|---|---|
| Left side of face | Grade IV(weakness with asymmetry of mouth, forehead frowning-none, incomplete closure of eyes with efforts) | Grade II (slight weakness noticeable on close observation, normal symmetry at rest, forehead- moderate to good function, eye- complete closure with minimum effort, mouth- |
| Left side of face | Grade IV(weakness with asymmetry of mouth, forehead frowning-none, incomplete closure of eyes with efforts) | Slight asymmetry. |
| Right side of face | Grade I (normal facial function in all area) | Grade I (normal facial |
| Right side of face | Grade I (normal facial function in all area) | function in all area) |
Table 3: House-Brackmann’s grading.
Discussion
Acharya Charak has mentioned Nasya for Ardita in Vata Vyadhi Chikitsa [10]. In Ayurveda Nasya is considered best to control the disease above neck [11]. The process by which the drug is administered through nostrils is called Nasya [12]. According to Ayurveda the drug administered through nostrils reaches Shrungataka Marma & distributed in Murdha ( brain), Siramukha (opening of the blood vessels of Netra (eye), Karna (ear), Kantha (throat) etc. finally scratches the morbid Dosha from supra clavicular region completely just like removing Munja grass from its stem [13]. According to modern science there is no direct route for pharmaco-dynamic consideration between nose & cranial organ because blood brain barrier is a strict security system of human brain. But the direct transportation can be possible through two pathways – Vascular & lymphatic. Vascular path transportation is possible through the pooling of nasal venous blood to the facial vein, which naturally occurs. Just at the opposite entrance, the inferior opthalamic vein also pool in the facial vein. As both facial & opthalamic vein have no veinal valves in between, so blood may drain on either side. That is to say the blood from facial vein can enter cavournus venous sinus of brain in reverse direction. Thus, such a pooling of blood from nasal vein to veinous sinuses of brain, is more likely in the head lowered position due to gravity. On these lines, the drug absorption into meninges & related parts of intracranial organs. Drug transportation by lymphatic path, can reach direct into the C.S.F. it is known that arachanoid matter sleeve is extended to the submucosal area of the nose along with olfactory nerve.
Here in this case the patient was given Sthanik Abhayanga & Swedana prior to the Nasya therapy. Sthanika Abhayanga was done with Go-Ghrita followed by Sthanik Dashmoola Kwath Naadi Sweda. It dilates the micro-blood vessels of face & enhances the blood circulation to that area. The increased blood flow to the peripheral arterioles accelerates the fast drug absorption & results in fast improvement.Improved blood supply to particular area of face result in nourishment of facial muscle & increases strength of facial muscle to work properly.
Mashbaladi Pachan Kashaya Nasya was given to the patient. It reaches to Shringataka Marma from where it spread into various Srotas (vessels & nerve) and controls the vitiated Vata Dosha. Not only have this drugs of Mashbaladi Panchan Kashaya also had additional property to pacify the vitiated Vata Dosha. They have anti-inflammatory and analgesic effect which gives relief in the symptoms. Kavala with luke warm water followed by Dhoompana after Nasya Karma removes the remaining Doshas which enhance the efficacy of treatment. Thus, helps to improve proper muscle functioning by pacifying the vitiated Vata Dosha & strengthening the muscles.
Conclusion
Here the patient is treated with Ayurvedic principles of Ardita & got marked improvement within one week without any side effect or recurrence. All the observation was done on the basis of clinical presentation & graded according to house- brookmans scale. Before the treatment the patient was unable to smile, had difficulty in speech, closure of eyelid, frowning, altered taste & smell. With the internal herbal preparation & Panchkarma therapy she got improvement in all the symptoms. After the completion two sitting of Nasya therapy & 60 days of internal herbal medication she got relief from all the symptoms successfully. From this study we can conclude that Ardita can be managed successfully by Ayurvedic principles. However, this is a single case study; similar studies are needed to be done on a large scale to establish statistical significance of the present line of treatment.
References
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Sutra Sthana 12/8.
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Sutra Sthana 20/11.
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Sutra Sthana 28/42.
-
Kaviraj Ambikadut Shashtri 2016 Ayurved-tatva- sandipika Hindi commentary of Sushruta Samhita. Chaukhambha publication, New Delhi, Nidana Sthana 1/69-71.
-
Kaviraj Atridev Gupt 2016 Vidyotini hindi commentary on Astangahridyam. Chaukhamba Prakashan, Varanasi, , Nidana Sthana 15/36.
-
Bell’s Palsy Fact Sheet from Wikipedia.
-
Victor M, Martin J (1994) Harrison’s Principles of internal Medicine. 13th (Edn.), New York, Mc Graw-hill, 2347-2352.
-
Prescott CAJ 1988 Idiopathic Facial Nerve Palsy (the effect of treatment with steroid). J Laryngol Otol 102:403-407.
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Chikitsa Sthana 28/39-42.
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Chikitsa Sthana 28/99.
-
Kashinath, Gorakhnath, Rajeshwar Shastri 2018 Savimarsh Vidyotini hindi commentary of Charak Samhita. Chaukhambha Prakashana, Varanasi, Sutra Sthana 5/61-62.
-
Kaviraj Ambikadut Shashtri 2016 Ayurved-tatva- sandipika Hindi commentary of Sushruta Samhita. Chaukhambha publication, New Delhi, Chikitsa Sthana 40/21.
-
Kaviraj Atridev Gupt 2016 Vidyotini hindi commentary on Samghra. Chaukhamba Prakashan, Varanasi, Sutra Sthana 29/3.
- Management of Ear Keloid with Ksharsutra: A Case Study
- Yoga and Global Sustainability: A Holistic Path to One Earth, One Health
- Autoimmune Diseases in Ayurveda: A Narrative Review with Classical and Modern Perspectives
- Management of Cluster Headache Associated with Pituitary Apophysitis by CERT (Chakrasiddh Energy Release Technique): A Case Report on Energy Rebalancing
- Zygophyllum Geslini Coss : Biochemicals and Antioxidant Activity
- Observations of a Beginner Vaidya